Serving Lake Mary, FL & Seminole County
Lake Mary Property Management
The Listing Real Estate Management is a full-service Lake Mary property management company. We lease, manage, and maintain single-family homes, townhomes, condos, and multifamily rentals across Lake Mary and the rest of Seminole County. Hospitality is built into everything we do, so owners get a local team that picks up the phone and residents who are happy to renew. Whether your rental is near Lake Mary's office parks, close to the SunRail station, or anywhere between Lake Mary, Sanford, and Orlando, our Lake Mary property managers are ready to protect your investment. Start with a free, in-depth rental analysis to see what your home should rent for.
How Much Can I Get for Rent?The Best Lake Mary Property Management Company
We offer full-service property management in Lake Mary, FL with a personal, proactive approach to residential management. Every owner gets a dedicated, licensed property manager who knows the home, the neighborhood, and the people living there.
Lake Mary is home to regional offices for companies like Deloitte, JPMorgan Chase, and Verizon, and a lot of the people who work there rent. Our team has managed Central Florida rentals for more than 15 years. On average, the homes we market lease in under 30 days, and we charge just two fees for full-service management. You'll notice the difference in the first month.
Talk to a Lake Mary property manager: 407-792-5900What Do We Do as Your Lake Mary Property Managers?
Owning a rental property in Lake Mary, Florida can be an excellent investment. Renters here want short commutes to the city's office parks, Seminole County schools, and quick access to I-4 and SunRail. But the wrong property management company can turn a good Lake Mary rental into an expensive headache. Here's how we protect our owners.
Property Management 1: Marketing & Leasing
01. Professional photos, video tours, and drone photography for every home we manage.
02. Maximum exposure: your Lake Mary rental is listed on 250+ rental websites.
03. Showings 7 days a week. On average, our homes lease in under 30 days.
Property Management 2: Tenant Screening
01. A thorough screening process that finds responsible, qualified residents for long-term rental success.
02. Every applicant is checked for credit history, debt-to-income ratio, nationwide evictions, criminal background, income and employment, and two years of rental history.
03. We'd rather wait a few extra days for the right tenant than rush in the fast one.
Property Management 3: Rent Collection
01. Rent collection that's simple and efficient for owners and residents.
02. Residents pay rent online through their resident portal, 24/7/365.
03. You get paid faster. Owner draws go straight to your bank account by direct deposit.
Property Management 4: Maintenance & Repairs
01. Fast, quality maintenance that protects your Lake Mary rental property.
02. A 24/7 emergency maintenance line, so your home is covered around the clock.
03. Licensed, bonded, and insured local vendors, billed at cost with no upcharge or added maintenance fees.
Property Management 5: Rental Property Accounting
01. Your property manager tracks your Lake Mary rental's financials every month.
02. Detailed monthly owner statements prepared by a professional bookkeeper.
03. Statements show income, expenses, liabilities, and equity, and you get a year-end 1099 at tax time.
Property Management 6: Rental Management Guarantees
01. Our 12-Month Tenant Guarantee: if a tenant we screened, approved, and managed moves out before their one-year lease ends, we'll find a new tenant free of charge.
02. Our satisfaction guarantee: if you're not happy with our service for any reason, cancel anytime with 30 days' written notice. We won't hold you hostage.
What Types of Rental Properties Do We Manage in Lake Mary and Central Florida?
Our Lake Mary property management company specializes in residential rentals throughout Lake Mary, Seminole County, and Greater Orlando.
Single-Family Home Property Management in Lake Mary
We call Central Florida home, and as a boutique property management company, we take pride in knowing every single-family home we manage. Lake Mary's rental homes range from established neighborhoods around the city's lakes to newer communities near Lake Mary Boulevard and the I-4 corridor. Whatever you own, we'll keep it maintained and earning for as long as we manage it.
Townhome & Condo Property Management in Lake Mary, Florida
Our rental property managers are experts in townhome and condominium management, including the HOA and association rules that come with many Lake Mary communities. Owning a Lake Mary investment property should be a pleasant and profitable experience, and we handle the details that keep it that way.
Apartment & Multifamily Property Management in Lake Mary
We offer full-service apartment and multifamily property management in Lake Mary and throughout Central Florida. Duplexes, small apartment buildings, and larger communities all need an experienced team for leasing, maintenance, and financial reporting. That's where our years of multifamily experience pay off for you and your rental property.
What Central Florida Rental Owners Say About The Listing
I left a larger property management company and thankfully found The Listing Orlando. Jobe with The Listing Real Estate Management is phenomenal. They are responsive and extremely quick to address items with my rental property. The Listing is creative in getting rental properties rented, even in out of season times. I am most thankful for their follow through; They don’t need to be asked to complete something or to follow up with a tenant or vendor. I recommend The Listing constantly to anyone looking for property management.
Courtney R.
Rental Property Owner
Award-Winning Lake Mary Property Management
We're proud to be a trusted source for Lake Mary property management services. With more than 15 years of property management experience behind us, you can feel at ease knowing every part of your Lake Mary rental property is protected. The Listing Real Estate Management is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (CQ1056007), and our team belongs to the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM), the Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM), the Orlando Regional REALTOR® Association, and the National Association of REALTORS®.
As a leading property management company in Orlando and Central Florida, we were named Silver, Best Property Management Company in the Orlando Sentinel's Central Florida Favorites (2025 and 2026), voted #3 Best Property Management Company in Orlando by Rentce, listed among the Best Professional Property Management Companies in Orlando by Roofstock, and named a Top Property Management Company in Orlando by Expertise.
About Lake Mary, Florida
Lake Mary, Florida is a Seminole County city about 19 miles north of downtown Orlando. It was incorporated in 1973 and has grown into a major office hub north of Orlando, with regional operations for AAA, Deloitte, JPMorgan Chase, Verizon, and Liberty Mutual. The Lake Mary SunRail station connects the city to downtown Orlando, I-4 runs along its western edge, and Colonial TownPark gives residents a walkable mix of shops, restaurants, and offices. In 2024, a Lake Mary team won the Little League World Series.
Lake Mary's rental market is steady. The population grew from about 11,500 in 2000 to nearly 16,800 at the 2020 Census, and the city's employers keep bringing professionals to the area. Renters include corporate transferees, young families who want Seminole County schools, and commuters headed to Orlando. Well-kept homes that are priced right don't sit long here.
Allow The Listing Real Estate Management to be your boutique Lake Mary property management service provider. We strive to provide the best property management services to the owners and residents of Lake Mary, and our goal is to manage every part of your Lake Mary rental property effectively and efficiently.
We also manage rentals in nearby Sanford, Oviedo, and Winter Park.
Lake Mary Property Management FAQs
Straight answers to the questions Lake Mary rental owners ask us most.
How much does property management cost in Lake Mary, FL?
The Listing charges two fees for full-service property management in Lake Mary: a leasing fee of 75% of one month's rent when we place a tenant, and a monthly management fee of 8–10%. There are no setup fees and no renewal fees. Owners with multiple properties or units can ask about our TL Investor Rate. See full pricing.
What does a Lake Mary property manager do?
A full-service Lake Mary property manager handles the day-to-day work of owning a rental home. At The Listing, that includes pricing and marketing your property, showings, tenant screening, lease preparation and signing, move-in inspections, rent collection, maintenance and 24/7 emergency repairs, lease enforcement, routine inspections, monthly owner statements, and a year-end 1099.
How long does it take to rent a house in Lake Mary?
On average, the homes we manage lease in under 30 days. We list every rental on 250+ websites with professional photos and a virtual tour, and we show homes 7 days a week. Price, condition, and time of year all affect how fast a home rents, which is why every owner starts with a free rental analysis.
How much rent can I get for my Lake Mary home?
It depends on size, location, condition, and the community. As of October 2026, Rentometer's data put the average three-bedroom rental in Lake Mary around $2,600 a month and four-plus-bedroom homes around $3,200. For a number specific to your property, request a free rental analysis.
What areas around Lake Mary do you serve?
We manage rental properties throughout Lake Mary (ZIP code 32746) and the rest of Seminole County, along with Sanford, Oviedo, Winter Park, Orlando, and the rest of Central Florida. Our office is at 300 S Orange Ave #1000 in downtown Orlando, and office visits are by appointment.
Can I cancel my property management agreement?
Yes. If you're not happy with our service for any reason, you can cancel with 30 days' written notice. We also back our placements with a 12-Month Tenant Guarantee: if a tenant we screened, approved, and managed moves out before the end of their one-year lease, we'll find a new tenant free of charge.
Is Lake Mary a good place to own a rental property?
For a lot of investors, yes. Lake Mary's corporate employers bring a steady flow of professional renters, Seminole County schools draw families, and SunRail and I-4 make the commute to Orlando easy. Like any market, your results depend on buying the right home at the right price and managing it well.
Ready to Have Your Lake Mary Rental Property Managed by The Listing?
Tell us about your Lake Mary rental and a local property manager will reach out. Prefer to talk now? Call 407-792-5900.
"*" indicates required fields